Efforts to establish international rules on the use of lethal autonomous weapons collapsed in Geneva this week, as United Nations-backed negotiations ended without a legally binding agreement. Diplomats confirmed that while countries agreed to continue discussions, no consensus was reached to launch formal negotiations on a treaty restricting so-called “killer robots.”
The week-long talks, held under the framework of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW), concluded late Friday after participating states failed to overcome deep divisions. According to multiple sources, Russia played a significant role in slowing progress, with some delegates describing the country’s actions as “filibustering.”
Most countries at the conference supported the need to regulate lethal autonomous weapons, but the process requires full consensus for any decision. The United States and Russia, both major military powers, resisted moves that could limit their ability to develop and deploy advanced autonomous systems, citing national security concerns and the ongoing high-tech arms race.
Seven countries—Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand, and Panama—had submitted a proposal to launch negotiations for a legally binding agreement on autonomous weapons, but this initiative did not receive the necessary backing from all participants. Instead, delegates agreed to continue discussions on possible international rules, with a view to developing proposals by 2028.
The International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) issued a strong warning during the talks, urging states to act now to ensure meaningful human control over the use of force. The ICRC argued that the risks of delegating life-and-death decisions to machines are too great, and called for immediate negotiations on a new protocol to regulate autonomous weapons.
UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres had previously set a deadline for the launch of talks toward regulation, adding urgency to this year’s meeting. Advocacy groups and some diplomats described the outcome as a missed opportunity, warning that the lack of a dedicated treaty leaves a critical gap in international humanitarian law as artificial intelligence transforms the battlefield.
The talks took place as the use of AI and autonomous systems in warfare is rapidly expanding. Scenarios involving armed drones and other autonomous platforms have raised concerns about the potential for civilian casualties and the erosion of human accountability in armed conflict.
According to the Associated Press, the issue of human control over autonomous weapons was a central point of debate, with many states and civil society organizations insisting that machines should never be allowed to make life-and-death decisions independently. However, the absence of consensus among major powers stalled any move toward binding restrictions.
Observers noted that the draft outcome of the conference appears designed to keep the issue within the CCW’s consensus-based process, potentially delaying meaningful action for years. Some participants warned that further delay could undermine the credibility of the CCW and its ability to address emerging security challenges.
Why it matters
The collapse of negotiations in Geneva leaves the international community without a dedicated, legally binding treaty to regulate lethal autonomous weapons, despite growing concerns from humanitarian organizations and many governments. The ICRC and advocacy groups have emphasized that the lack of clear rules increases the risk that machines could be used to make decisions over life and death without meaningful human oversight.
This outcome highlights the persistent divide between major military powers—such as the United States and Russia—and the majority of countries that support stronger regulation. With AI-driven weapons systems already being deployed, the absence of international restrictions could accelerate an arms race and complicate efforts to protect civilians in future conflicts, as noted by the Associated Press and the ICRC.
As discussions are set to continue over the next two years, the focus will remain on whether states can bridge their differences and agree on effective measures to ensure human control over emerging technologies in warfare. The credibility of the CCW process and the broader international legal framework for armed conflict are now under increased scrutiny, according to participants and observers at the talks.
The image accompanying this article is an AI-generated illustrative depiction inspired by the actual scene of the event.































